Improve usability of "Follow" button in issue queue

Idea#37

Stage: Active

Campaign: Drupal.org

Despite the awesome "Follow" button that was added to the top of issues, I still see a lot of people posting "subscribe" or "+1" in the issue queues. I think there are two reasons for this:

1) If you aren't logged in, you don't see the Follow button

2) It only appears at the top of the issue, but people are going to be most tempted to "subscribe" when they have read to the bottom of the thread and determined that the conversation is incomplete and they want to get updates.

The fixes I'd suggest:

1) The Follow button appears to anonymous users, but takes you to the login page.

2) The Follow button appears at both the top and bottom of the issue. The one at the bottom should be positioned above/below/inside the comment form, wherever it is most likely to catch the eye of someone about to post a quick "subscribe" comment.

3) Comment validation should include a check for basic "subscribe" posts, and the error should remind people to click the Follow button.

Tags

Submitted by

Related *.drupal.org issue/discussion: http://drupal.org/node/34496

Feedback Score

48 votes
Voting Disabled

Idea Details

Vote Activity (latest 20 votes)

  1. Disagreed
  2. Agreed
  3. Agreed
  4. Agreed
  5. Agreed
  6. Agreed
  7. Disagreed
  8. Agreed
  9. Agreed
  10. Agreed
  11. Agreed
  12. Agreed
  13. Agreed
  14. Agreed
  15. Agreed
  16. Agreed
  17. Agreed
  18. Agreed
  19. Agreed
  20. Agreed
(latest 20 votes)

Events

  1. The idea was posted

Assessment

Comments

  1. Comment
    thorovsky

    Neither (1) nor (2) of your reasons apply to me - I sometimes stick 'subscribe' to make the importance of the issue more visible.

  2. Comment
    ramaro99

    I think we should see the number of followers on each issue, and have a page where we can see all issues that one is following (I didn't find a page like this).

    Comments on this comment

    1. Comment
      rice.shawn

      It seems the below idea referenced by james.williams isn't there, or, at least, the link doesn't work. I submitted something similar (http://drupal-association.ideascale.com/a/dtd/Indicate-Number-of-Followers-on-an-Issue/101436-18300). It seems that the idea in this queue is good but contingent on the idea discussed here. The idea of a count was brought up in the issue queue of AdvAgg (http://drupal.org/node/1171546)

  3. Comment
    jthorson

    hook_form_validate: If exists($keyword("subscribe")) {do follow;} ;)

  4. Comment
    markwkoester

    I think we can improve the follow button from a project / issue maintainer by showing NUMBER OF FOLLOWS.

  5. Comment
    SHELDONKREGER

    This idea is simple and logical.